Everyone starts with basic RAG: embed your documents, retrieve top-k results, stuff them into a prompt. It works surprisingly well—until it doesn't. Agentic RAG adds reasoning and iteration, but comes with complexity and cost. Let's break down when each approach makes sense.
Basic RAG: The Standard Approach
One pass. Simple. The query doesn't change, retrieval happens once, and the LLM generates a response from whatever was retrieved.
When Basic RAG Works
- • Simple factual queries — "What's our return policy?"
- • Well-indexed content — Queries match document language closely
- • Single-source answers — Answer exists in one document
- • High-quality embeddings — Strong semantic matching
Where Basic RAG Fails
- • Multi-hop questions — "Compare our pricing to competitor X's"
- • Ambiguous queries — User intent unclear from initial query
- • Information gaps — First retrieval misses relevant content
- • Reasoning required — Answer requires synthesis across documents
Agentic RAG: The Reasoning Layer
Agentic RAG adds an AI agent that decides what to retrieve, evaluates results, and iterates until it has enough information.
Agentic RAG Patterns
Different flavors of agentic RAG solve different problems:
Self-RAG
Agent decides when retrieval is needed vs. answering from knowledge. Avoids unnecessary retrieval for simple questions.
Corrective RAG (CRAG)
Evaluates retrieved documents for relevance. Discards irrelevant results, triggers web search if knowledge base lacks answer.
Adaptive RAG
Analyzes query complexity and routes to appropriate strategy: simple lookup, iterative search, or multi-source synthesis.
Multi-hop RAG
For questions requiring information chains. "Who is the CEO of the company that makes our main competitor's database?"
Comparison Table
| Factor | Basic RAG | Agentic RAG |
|---|---|---|
| Latency | 100-500ms | 1-10 seconds |
| Cost per query | $0.01-0.05 | $0.10-1.00 |
| Implementation | Simple | Complex |
| Query complexity | Simple factual | Complex, multi-step |
| Self-correction | None | Yes |
| Predictability | High | Variable |
Decision Framework
Use this flowchart to decide:
- 1. Are queries simple and well-defined?
Yes → Start with Basic RAG - 2. Is basic RAG answering correctly 80%+ of the time?
Yes → Keep Basic RAG. Optimize chunking/embeddings first. - 3. Do failures require multiple retrieval rounds?
Yes → Consider Agentic RAG - 4. Is latency critical (<1 second)?
Yes → Optimize basic RAG; agentic may be too slow - 5. Can you afford 5-10x cost increase?
No → Improve basic RAG first
Hybrid Approach
Many production systems use both:
Route simple queries (80%+) through basic RAG for speed and cost efficiency. Reserve agentic capabilities for queries that need them.
Implementation Tips
If you decide to implement agentic RAG:
- • Set iteration limits — Max 3-5 retrieval rounds to prevent runaway costs
- • Cache reformulated queries — Similar queries can reuse planning
- • Log everything — Agent decisions, retrievals, evaluations for debugging
- • Define clear stopping criteria — When does the agent decide it has enough?
- • Use smaller models for routing — Query classification doesn't need GPT-4
Need help choosing?
We benchmark your queries to determine the right RAG architecture for your use case.
Contact me